Poking Holes in Your Practice Methods

 

🚑 Prehospital Needle Decompression: What EMS Providers Need to Know in 2025

By CrashCart Kelly

Tension pneumothorax is a killer. Without quick intervention, it can rapidly progress to obstructive shock and cardiac arrest. In the field, needle decompression remains one of the most critical—and time-sensitive—skills an EMS provider can perform.

But like everything in medicine, our approach to this procedure has evolved. This post breaks down the latest, evidence-based guidance on how to perform needle decompression right—from site selection to needle length, and when you should (and shouldn’t) do it.

🎯 When Should You Decompress?

Needle decompression isn’t for every trauma patient with low sats. According to recent studies, overuse leads to iatrogenic pneumothorax, vascular injury, and poor outcomes.

✅ Perform needle decompression only if your patient has:

  • Chest trauma or barotrauma and

  • Severe respiratory distress or hypoxia

  • Unilateral decreased or absent breath sounds

  • Hypotension or signs of obstructive shock

  • Increasing airway pressure or capnography changes (if ventilated)

  • Tracheal deviation or JVD (late and unreliable signs)

🔍 A 2022 study found that 25% of patients who got prehospital needle decompression didn’t need it—and some were harmed because of it.

📍 Location, Location, Location: The Best Site Has Changed

Forget the old 2nd intercostal space at the midclavicular line (2nd ICS-MCL)—that site has a high failure rate.

🟢 Best site in 2025:
→ 4th or 5th intercostal space at the anterior or mid-axillary line (AAL/MAL)

Why switch?

  • Chest wall is thinner there (even in obese patients)

  • Less risk of hitting internal mammary vessels

  • Better access when the patient is supine or extricated

📚 A 2023 meta-analysis showed up to 96% success at the 5th ICS-AAL compared to 79% at the 2nd ICS-MCL.

🧰 Needle & Catheter: Size Matters

The biggest reason needle decompression fails? Not reaching the pleural space.

Use:

  • 14-gauge catheter (10G if your service uses specialized kits)

  • At least 3.25 inches (8 cm) in length

  • Avoid anything shorter unless your patient is an infant

EMS agencies are now stocking longer, kink-resistant catheters or even chest decompression kits designed specifically for field use.

🛠️ Step-by-Step: How to Do It Right

  1. Find the landmark:

    • Primary: 5th ICS-AAL (nipple level, mid-axillary line)

    • Alternate: 2nd ICS-MCL (if lateral site is inaccessible)

  2. Insert needle:

    • Go perpendicular to the chest wall

    • Aim just over the rib to avoid the neurovascular bundle

    • Advance fully to the hub

    • Listen/feel for a whoosh of air

  3. Leave catheter in place and secure it

  4. Attach a one-way valve, if available

  5. Monitor closely for signs of improvement—or re-tensioning

⚠️ Common Pitfalls and Complications

Here’s what you need to watch out for:

  • ❌ Failure to reach pleura – use a longer needle!

  • ❌ Wrong site – especially MCL placement too medially

  • ❌ Kinked catheter – secure it carefully

  • ❌ Injury to lungs, vessels, or heart – especially with improper technique

🧪 A 2023 review in Journal of Special Operations Medicine showed a 6–15% complication rate in EMS-performed decompressions—most due to landmarking or catheter issues.

✋ What If It Fails? Consider Finger Thoracostomy

In systems with trained ALS providers, finger thoracostomy is gaining ground as a safer and more reliable method, especially when:

  • Needle decompression fails

  • The patient is in traumatic arrest

  • Chest wall thickness exceeds catheter length

Studies from 2024 report higher success rates (95–98%) and fewer complications than needle decompression—but it requires more training and sterile technique.

🧾 Quick Recap: EMS Best Practices for Needle Decompression

✅ Do This❌ Don’t Do This
Use ≥8 cm (3.25") 14G catheterUse short IV catheters
Prefer 5th ICS at AAL/MALDefault to 2nd ICS unless necessary
Insert over rib, full depthStop halfway or go under the rib
Secure catheter and monitorForget reassessment
Use only with clear indications“Just in case” decompressions

📚 References

  1. Dominguez, A. et al. (2022). Prehospital Needle Decompression Complications. Injury, 53(12), 2831–2837.

  2. Harmsen, A.M.K., et al. (2023). Site Selection and Catheter Efficacy. WJES, 18(1), 22.

  3. Thompson, P., et al. (2023). Risk in Prehospital Needle Thoracostomy. JSOM, 23(1), 45–51.

  4. International Journal of Paramedicine. (2024). Finger Thoracostomy: A Safer Alternative?

  5. NAEMSP. (2024). Clinical Guidelines for Needle Thoracostomy.

  6. StatPearls Publishing. (2024). Needle Thoracostomy. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK441898/

📣 Final Thoughts

Needle decompression is still a must-know skill—but not one to take lightly. As equipment and evidence evolve, so must our protocols. If you’re in EMS, make sure your agency stocks the right gear and your team is trained in the current best practices.


#bloggingfromthebay

— CrashCart Kelly

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Welcome!

  🩺 Welcome to The Medic Minute Your Source for Emergency Medicine Practice Updates By a CEN Who Lives It Hi there, and welcome to the blog! I'm a Certified Emergency Nurse (CEN) with years of frontline experience in the controlled chaos we call the Emergency Department. If you’ve ever triaged a patient, started compressions in seconds flat, or had to make a clinical decision with limited information and even less time — you’re in the right place. I started this blog with a simple goal:  to keep emergency medicine professionals sharp, current, and connected . Guidelines change. Evidence evolves. And as much as we live in the thick of it, it’s not always easy to carve out time to stay updated. That’s where this space comes in. Here’s what you can expect: 🔄  Practice Guideline Updates  — from trauma protocols to airway algorithms. 🧠  Clinical Pearls & Pitfalls  — quick takeaways that could make or break a shift. 🛠  Real-World Application  — ...
Read more

Blood, Belmonts, and the Back of the Rig: A Guide to Mass Transfusion

“Activate MTP!”  That phrase has become one of the most defining moments of modern emergency and trauma nursing. We’ve come a long way from the days of blindly hanging fluids and praying for a stable pressure. Today, we have coordinated  massive transfusion protocols (MTPs) ,  Belmont rapid infusers , and—thanks to some bold EMS systems— prehospital blood products  already dripping before the stretcher even hits the door. But with new tools and protocols comes new responsibility—and a need to stay sharp on the  why , not just the  how . 🩸 What  Is  a Massive Transfusion Protocol? Massive transfusion  is usually defined as: >10 units of PRBCs within 24 hours , or >4 units in 1 hour with ongoing need , or Replacement of >50% of blood volume in 3 hours But practically? If your trauma team’s activating MTP, you know you're in the thick of it. MTPs are designed to: Restore  oxygen-carrying capacity  and  coagulation functi...
Read more